District Sentencing
Search

Reference

How the guidelines work

The Guidelines Manual is a book of the US Sentencing Commission. A court uses it to find the guideline range of a case. The range is given in months.

The Supreme Court made the guidelines advisory in United States v. Booker. A court can sentence outside the range.

Offence level

The offence level rates the offence. A higher level gives a longer range. The Commission explains it in these words.

The severity level of an offense, ordinarily determined in Chapters Two and Three of the Guidelines Manual, and reflected on the vertical axis of the Sentencing Table.

US Sentencing Commission, Glossary, entry "Offense Level"

Each guideline of Chapter Two gives a base offence level. The Commission calls it the starting point. Later steps can add levels or take them away. The result is the final offence level.

The table of the Commission has offence levels 1 to 43.

Criminal history category

The criminal history category is a number from I to VI. It comes from the earlier convictions of the person. A higher category gives a longer range.

The category assigned to the defendant based on the defendant’s prior criminal history.

US Sentencing Commission, Glossary, entry "Criminal History Category"

The guideline range

The Sentencing Table crosses the offence level with the criminal history category. The cell gives the range in months.

The Commission gives an example. The range for offence level 15 and category III is 24 to 30 months. The Commission writes this in Chapter Five of the Manual.

A law can set a shortest sentence, which is a mandatory minimum. The Commission explains it in these words.

A non-discretionary penalty required by statute.

US Sentencing Commission, Glossary, entry "Mandatory Minimum"

Within, above and below the range

The Commission puts each sentence in a group. The group depends on the place of the sentence relative to the range and on the reason. The site joins the groups of the Commission in four groups.

  • Within range. The sentence is inside the range. In fiscal years 2018 to 2025, 47% of sentences were in this group.
  • Above range. The sentence is longer than the range. 3% of sentences were in this group.
  • Below range, government sponsored. The sentence is shorter than the range after a motion of the government. 29% of sentences were in this group.
  • Below range, other. The sentence is shorter than the range with no motion of the government. 21% of sentences were in this group.

A sentence outside the range is a departure or a variance. The Commission explains both.

A sentence outside the guideline range in accordance with the Guidelines Manual.

US Sentencing Commission, Glossary, entry "Departure"

A sentence outside the applicable guideline range (above or below) for any reason that is not in accordance with the guidelines or policy statements.

US Sentencing Commission, Glossary, entry "Variance"

The most common departure is for substantial assistance. The government must ask the court for it.

What the figures do not tell

A share below the range in a district depends on the mix of offences. It also depends on how often the government asks for a shorter sentence, and on the practice of the courts. The datafile does not separate these causes.

A figure on this site describes past cases. It does not describe one case. The site gives no advice and cannot predict a sentence.

Last checked against the Sentencing Commission pages: